Attorney scorecard

Live · 13,396 cases in database · latest filing 2026-05-12

Outcome, award and timing statistics for every attorney in the registry, computed directly from the decisions in this database. Use the condition filter to compare like with like: a docket heavy in SIRVA settlements will always show a higher win rate than one heavy in contested encephalopathy claims, so the headline win rate mostly reflects case mix. The contested win rate column counts only reasoned decisions, where a Special Master actually ruled on entitlement.

Attorneys shown

109

with at least 15 cases

Petitioner win rate

77%

13,115 decided cases

Median award

$80K

9,371 compensated cases

Median time to decision

21 mo

12,837 dated cases

Attorney scorecard

Attorney	Cases	Win rate	Contested win rate (n)	Settled share	Median award	Median time	Most common condition
Leah VaSahnja Durant	900	96%	77% (113)	84%	$82K	25 mo	SIRVA
Ronald Craig Homer	888	88%	53% (146)	84%	$90K	25 mo	SIRVA
Maximillian J. Muller	524	94%	73% (52)	88%	$72K	16 mo	SIRVA
Jeffrey S. Pop	499	96%	75% (40)	90%	$73K	19 mo	SIRVA
Paul R. Brazil	388	95%	78% (32)	87%	$68K	17 mo	SIRVA
Andrew D. Downing	312	50%	27% (81)	84%	$75K	21 mo	Other / multiple
Amy A. Senerth	304	80%	40% (62)	84%	$60K	23 mo	SIRVA
Bridget Candace McCullough	286	88%	73% (44)	80%	$60K	22 mo	SIRVA
John Robert Howie	286	93%	73% (26)	88%	$75K	17 mo	SIRVA
Leigh Finfer	241	90%	73% (48)	81%	$55K	22 mo	SIRVA
Mark T. Sadaka	229	53%	15% (60)	90%	$60K	36 mo	Other / multiple
Jonathan Joseph Svitak	226	83%	61% (31)	86%	$46K	28 mo	SIRVA
Nancy Routh Meyers	202	84%	77% (22)	86%	$102K	21 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
David John Carney	200	82%	75% (80)	53%	$71K	27 mo	SIRVA
Laura Levenberg	171	91%	61% (31)	84%	$55K	21 mo	SIRVA
Edward M. Kraus	169	79%	44% (41)	80%	$100K	25 mo	SIRVA
Jimmy A. Zgheib	167	97%	84% (19)	86%	$70K	17 mo	SIRVA
Anne Carrion Toale	166	85%	64% (14)	88%	$120K	21 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Danielle Strait	163	91%	50% (22)	89%	$120K	19 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Diana Lynn Stadelnikas	148	83%	50% (18)	91%	$98K	20 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Alison H. Haskins	147	92%	77% (13)	90%	$115K	14 mo	SIRVA
Isaiah Richard Kalinowski	145	86%	48% (25)	84%	$120K	20 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Amber Diane Wilson	137	92%	36% (14)	93%	$120K	13 mo	SIRVA
Lawrence R. Cohan	136	87%	57% (14)	91%	$130K	18 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Michael G. McLaren	134	83%	33% (24)	90%	$80K	22 mo	SIRVA
Richard Gage	126	55%	48% (63)	49%	$172K	47 mo	Other / multiple
William E. Cochran, Jr.	119	84%	57% (21)	86%	$90K	19 mo	SIRVA
Jessica Olins	110	95%	81% (16)	82%	$81K	21 mo	SIRVA
Renee J. Gentry	108	59%	49% (43)	57%	$101K	35 mo	SIRVA
Robert J. Krakow	108	47%	25% (24)	85%	$82K	48 mo	Other / multiple
Bruce William Slane	106	89%	67% (15)	89%	$62K	21 mo	SIRVA
Howard Scott Gold	97	69%	30% (20)	89%	$72K	25 mo	Other / multiple
Clifford J. Shoemaker	95	51%	23% (39)	76%	$148K	42 mo	Other / multiple
Diana Stadelnikas Sedar	90	87%	10% (10)	94%	$100K	15 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Shealene Priscilla Mancuso	88	86%	92% (12)	80%	$68K	23 mo	SIRVA
Joseph Alexander Vuckovich	86	85%	25% (16)	88%	$92K	25 mo	SIRVA
Glen Howard Sturtevant, Jr.	80	92%	62% (13)	89%	$60K	23 mo	SIRVA
Elizabeth Martin Muldowney	78	92%	40% (10)	91%	$93K	17 mo	SIRVA
Ramon Rodriguez, III	74	90%	43% (7)	89%	$100K	24 mo	SIRVA
Matthew F. Belanger	70	97%	100% (9)	87%	$90K	17 mo	SIRVA
Sean Franks Greenwood	67	50%	29% (28)	71%	$95K	28 mo	SIRVA
Carol L. Gallagher	67	74%	22% (9)	88%	$73K	13 mo	Other / multiple
Richard H. Moeller	63	85%	36% (11)	82%	$71K	23 mo	SIRVA
Jerome A. Konkel	63	94%	83% (6)	90%	$66K	20 mo	SIRVA
Scott William Rooney	59	56%	23% (13)	88%	$55K	24 mo	SIRVA
Phyllis Widman	55	48%	17% (23)	84%	$51K	28 mo	SIRVA
Milton Clay Ragsdale, IV	53	79%	25% (12)	93%	$112K	25 mo	SIRVA
Franklin John Caldwell, Jr.	52	87%	33% (6)	91%	$125K	28 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Scott B. Taylor	51	94%	80% (5)	90%	$66K	16 mo	SIRVA
Kathleen Margaret Loucks	49	81%	36% (11)	87%	$60K	20 mo	SIRVA
Daniel Alholm	48	98%	80% (5)	91%	$61K	14 mo	SIRVA
Lisa A. Roquemore	47	77%	29% (14)	79%	$185K	38 mo	Other / multiple
Randall G. Knutson	47	70%	25% (12)	81%	$141K	21 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Brian L. Cinelli	47	85%	55% (11)	82%	$95K	30 mo	SIRVA
Curtis R. Webb	46	57%	35% (23)	64%	$100K	46 mo	Other / multiple
John Beaulieu	46	86%	62% (8)	87%	$73K	19 mo	SIRVA
Emily Beth Ashe	44	82%	38% (8)	83%	$80K	27 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
F. John Caldwell, Jr.	44	74%	14% (7)	94%	$120K	21 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Catherine Wallace Costigan	43	100%	100% (8)	72%	$94K	19 mo	SIRVA
Michael A. Firestone	43	66%	23% (13)	85%	$90K	34 mo	SIRVA
John F. McHugh	41	18%	4% (26)	57%	$66K	65 mo	Autism spectrum disorder
Jessica Wallace	40	62%	17% (12)	87%	$70K	28 mo	SIRVA
Jeffrey A. Golvash	40	82%	20% (5)	90%	$50K	20 mo	Other / multiple
Brynna Gang	40	95%	86% (7)	81%	$56K	19 mo	SIRVA
Mark L. Krueger	38	47%	0% (12)	94%	$130K	17 mo	Other / multiple
Shealene Priscilla Wasserman	36	92%	86% (7)	73%	$90K	15 mo	SIRVA
Michael Adly Baseluos	35	85%	62% (8)	79%	$145K	31 mo	SIRVA
Douglas Lee Burdette	34	76%	40% (5)	85%	$70K	22 mo	SIRVA
Jessica Carin Huff	33	85%	75% (8)	68%	$107K	25 mo	SIRVA
Michael Andrew London	33	69%	22% (9)	77%	$100K	33 mo	Other / multiple
Theodore J. Hong	33	97%	n=2	91%	$96K	24 mo	SIRVA
David Charles Richards	32	75%	50% (8)	79%	$88K	32 mo	SIRVA
Elizabeth Kyla Abramson	32	97%	100% (7)	73%	$102K	19 mo	SIRVA
David Alexander Tierney	32	91%	n=3	93%	$58K	20 mo	SIRVA
Kate Gerayne Westad	31	94%	n=4	90%	$130K	20 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Rhonda Lorenz-Pignato	29	90%	86% (7)	77%	$61K	30 mo	SIRVA
Sylvia Chin-Caplan	28	57%	23% (13)	81%	$132K	47 mo	Other / multiple
Patricia A. Finn	28	39%	27% (15)	55%	$170K	45 mo	Other / multiple
Kelly Danielle Burdette	27	80%	n=3	95%	$96K	19 mo	SIRVA
Simina Vourlis	26	84%	n=3	95%	$155K	20 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Braden Andrew Blumenstiel	25	40%	9% (11)	90%	$80K	39 mo	Other / multiple
Christopher Williams	25	100%	n=0	100%	$40K	19 mo	SIRVA
Meredith Daniels	25	76%	45% (11)	74%	$145K	29 mo	Other / multiple
Joseph P. Shannon	24	96%	n=1	100%	$51K	12 mo	SIRVA
Wendy Cox	21	95%	n=3	85%	$53K	13 mo	SIRVA
Bradley S. Freedberg	21	62%	0% (6)	92%	$62K	26 mo	SIRVA
Elizabeth Hess	21	100%	n=0	100%	$59K	13 mo	SIRVA
Howard Dale Mishkind	20	80%	n=4	75%	$105K	26 mo	SIRVA
Christina Ciampolillo	20	74%	58% (12)	50%	$182K	37 mo	Other / multiple
Joseph Pepper	20	65%	50% (8)	62%	$126K	22 mo	SIRVA
Jessica E. Choper	20	95%	n=1	95%	$81K	19 mo	SIRVA
Timothy James Lessman	20	80%	n=0	100%	$98K	15 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Bijan Esfandiari	19	0%	n=1	—	—	8 mo	Dysautonomia / POTS
Verne E. Paradie, Jr.	18	61%	33% (6)	73%	$92K	26 mo	Other / multiple
Elaine Whitfield Sharp	18	44%	0% (6)	71%	$225K	32 mo	Other / multiple
LeeAnne Pedrick	17	94%	n=2	75%	$101K	16 mo	SIRVA
Jubaile Abila	17	100%	n=1	94%	$50K	14 mo	SIRVA
Kathy Ann Lee	17	100%	n=0	94%	$140K	16 mo	SIRVA
Thomas P. Gallagher	16	38%	n=2	100%	$75K	12 mo	Other / multiple
Donald P. Edwards	16	73%	n=2	91%	$110K	21 mo	Other / multiple
Kristina E. Grigorian	16	100%	n=2	81%	$95K	20 mo	SIRVA
Christopher E. Hultquist	16	88%	n=0	100%	$97K	19 mo	SIRVA
Timothy J. Mason	15	86%	n=1	100%	$58K	36 mo	SIRVA
Paul Adrian Green	15	50%	n=2	100%	$48K	26 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Lawrence Gene Michel	15	67%	20% (5)	90%	$128K	19 mo	Guillain-Barré Syndrome
Ann Mayhew Golski	15	100%	n=1	87%	$93K	14 mo	SIRVA
Daniel Henry Pfeifer	15	67%	n=1	100%	$101K	16 mo	SIRVA
David Gregory Rogers	15	67%	n=1	100%	$38K	16 mo	SIRVA
Robert T. Moxley	15	43%	0% (6)	33%	$59K	83 mo	Seizure disorder

Petitioner win rate, 15 highest-volume attorneys

Share of decided cases (compensated or entitlement granted) among compensated, entitlement, denied and dismissed.

Median award

Compensated cases with a recorded award, fee-only awards excluded.

Median months from filing to decision

Cases with both a filing date and a decision date.

Reading attorney-level results

Attorney attribution comes from the counsel line of each published decision and is normalised across spelling variants, so an attorney who moved between firms is counted once. Attorneys with fewer than fifteen cases are omitted here because a handful of outcomes says little; their full case lists remain on the attorney hub pages.

As with firms, the headline win rate is mostly a description of the docket an attorney carries. The contested column, restricted to reasoned entitlement decisions, is the closer proxy for litigation results, and the settled share shows how much of a practice is negotiated rather than tried.

How to read this. Win rate = compensated or entitlement-granted cases divided by all decided cases (compensated, entitlement granted, denied, dismissed). Dismissals include voluntary withdrawals. Settled share = wins resolved by stipulation or proffer rather than a ruling. Median award uses compensated cases with a recorded dollar award and excludes attorney-fee-only awards. Fields were extracted from the public decisions by an AI pipeline and spot-checked; individual values can be wrong, aggregates are robust. Cases before 2014 are sparse in this corpus.